Anthony Rapp Adam Pascal Ramin Karimloo Alfie Boe Andrew Lloyd Webber Eden Espinosa Sierra Boggess Rogers And Hammerstein Megan Hilty Elaine Paige Rachel Tucker Apache Najwajean Vittorio Grigolo Idina Menzel Talk Dirty Jonathan Larson Rodgers And Hammerstein Wende Snijders Sonic Mayhem Kristen Chenoweth Sonic Shane Archer Reed Hugh Panaro Don Davis David Arnold Emma Shapplin Hank Green Driftless Pony Club Rustie Aaron Tveit Phillipa Soo Selectracks Tom Milsom Lea Michele Original Broadway Cast Lin Manuel Miranda The Budos Band Epic North Original Off-Broadway Cast Anthony Ramos Daveed Diggs Leslie Odom Jr. Elise Luebbe Christopher Jackson Les Miserables Bo Burnham Josh Groban The Sunjays