Darren Criss Glee Cast Team Starkid Charlene Kaye Starkid Jim And The Povolos Dylan Saunders Jaime Lyn Beatty Straight No Chaser Idina Menzel Charlene Kaye And The Brilliant Eyes Oliver Boyd And The Remembralls Julie Andrews Kristin Chenoweth Talkfine Olivia Newton John John Travolta Chris Colfer Lea Salonga Sara Quin Tegan Quin Chameleon Circuit Draco And The Malfoys The Remus Lupins The Whomping Willows Computer Games Phil Phillips Molotov Jukebox Baumer David Garrett Naya Rivera Freelance Whales The Warblers Wild Ones James Durbin Hank Green Natalie Cole Mc Fly Original Broadway Cast The Glee Club The Blanks Sara Bareilles Louden Swain Burnham Broadway Musicals Britt Nicole Mika Elliot Minor Mackenzie Bourg