Laura Benanti Jason Robert Brown Natalie Weiss Audra Mcdonald Richard Rodgers Sutton Foster Scott Alan Laura Osnes Gavin Creel William Finn Patti Lupone Jeremy Jordan Stephen Sondheim Kristen Chenoweth Zachary Levi Bernadette Peters Adam Guettel David Yazbek Lea Salonga Original Broadway Cast Aaron Tveit Emile Pandolfi Sierra Boggess Broadway Musicals Sara Ramirez Alan Menken Idina Menzel Teal Wicks Jonathan Larson Original Off-Broadway Cast Brittain Ashford Christian Borle Andrew Lloyd Webber Meryl Streep Reed Deming Prairie Empire Lin-Manuel Miranda Frank Wildhorn Kelli O'Hara Bongos Ikwue Hugh Panaro Cleo Laine Vikki Carr Rogers And Hammerstein Pasek And Paul Gelsey Bell Ghost Quartet Dave Malloy Trixie Mattel